Reviews & Ratings for Nino's Pizza

4 Star Rating: Recommended

13 reviews

What users are saying:

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

09/26/02

New Yorks finest!

by dontigger at Citysearch

I visited Nino's for the first time thanks to my Daughter. I was raised in Buffalo and moved away, and never knew. BUT, Nino's has the BEST pizza I have ever had across the country. And I've been everywhere. It is still with me and that was 7 months ago..................DRT

4 Star Rating: Recommended

03/18/09

Never had a bad pie all these years

by shimmel at Citysearch

I have been getting pizza from Nino's for 30 years and as far as I can remember the flavor and texture of their pies has always been the same . I think it's some of the best pizza around and believe me , I've sampled a lot of others . It.s become a once a year treat when I visit and it never disappoints .

  • Pros: Always the same - very good
  • Cons: Getting too expensive
1 Star Rating: Poor

01/24/09

lOST ANOTHER REGULAR CUSTOMER

by BUFFALOPIZZALVR at Citysearch

WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO YOUR PIZZA?? WAS ONE OF THE BEST.............NOW ONLY THING I CAN SAY IS RED BARRON FROZEN PIZZA HAS MORE TASTE TO IT THAN THE LAST FEW I BOUGHT IN YOUR SHOP.......YUCK! I ACTUALLY THINK THAT TOPS MARKETS CARRY OUT IS EVEN BETTER THAN YOURS NOW,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,LETS GET BACK TO THE BASICS...WHAT YOU ONCE WERE.!!!!

  • Pros: SUBS! AND SALADS!!!
  • Cons: PIZZA///SERVICE////WINGS///PRICES,
1 Star Rating: Poor

10/06/08

was a former employee there. now i hate it.

by ANJONSisBetter67 at Citysearch

i use to love nino's but after working at the hamburg location i dislike it. do to the fact that people loved my wings. but now that i am gone the wings taste bad. they are not cooked at all. but i do have to say i will eat subs there and salads thats about it. i then found a new place to eat at its anjons pizza off of clark st. its a whole lot better.. i am satisfied with my new tastes.....

  • Pros: parking is bad/ people smoke in storage area.
  • Cons: slow...
2 Star Rating: Below Average

01/24/06

lost this customer

by rch54 at Citysearch

after being a "nino's" customer for yrs. i have to say i will no longer be getting my pizza from them. The last couple of times i've got pizza there the crust was very thin,the toppings fell off the slice as it was takin from the box.The overall quality was no longer there.This area is filled with places to get this kind of food,so i unfortunatly will move on to someone else.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

07/07/05

A previous rater

by teddybearguy at Citysearch

I think one of the previous people who rated Nino's is a bit egotistical. He thinks he's the only one behind Tony's fame? He doesn't know how to spell and his English has much to be desired. I think he is a fomer employee because he probably got fired and is talking about his sour grapes. With his time off now, I think he should go back to school. That's my opinion.

Nino's is a great place. The employees are great. The food is great.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

07/18/03

Amazing Pizza

by takingbacksunday at Citysearch

Nino's is a delicacy here in Buffalo. They have the best pizza around. It is always hot and steamy and has the most crispy crust. It's never soggy or undercooked. They really know what they're doing there. Add a little Nino's special bleu cheese on top and muah! a masterpiece. The best thing about Nino's, besides the great tasting pizza is that it's an awesome value. A broke college kid like myself can get a pie for fairly cheap and eat for three days!!! If you're in the area, definately stop by Nino's. P.S. The chicken fingers are awesome too! They're huge and you get a ton of them with curly fries!

  • Pros: Great pizza, Awesome value, Nice people
  • Cons: None
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/10/03

Makes me homesick

by ggmlester at Citysearch

I Moved away but when ever we're in West Seneca visiting family one meal is Pizza and Wings from Nino's. Haven't found any better and none compete in the Washington DC area!

  • Pros: Good Value, Prompt Service
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/09/03

Nino's in Hamburg!!!

by zcatfree at Citysearch

I moved out of state and whenever I come back home, you can find me at Nino's ordering one of their famous pizza, subs, or wings. Highly recommend.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

12/06/02

Southtowns Best

by Wags_Nags_Stables at Citysearch

For the inhabitants of the snowbelt area you at least can dine on some great pie. Nino's has been a long standing favorite of mine growing up in West Seneca. The quality of the food is fantastic.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

12/06/02

a fine slice of pie

by nicdoraz at Citysearch

Nino's simply makes a really fine slice of pie. When it's cooked right, and on busy nights make sure you ask for extra crispy, it is simply THE best pizza in Buffalo. Throw a little of their famous blue cheese on top of it, and it is a little bit of heaven here on earth. As a transplanted Buffalonian living in NYC, I have a standing date with Nino's whenever I am back home.

  • Pros: inexpensive, easy parking

Showing 1-10 of 13 reviews

Advertisement
Best of Citysearch
Time is running out!
Best of Citysearch Spa and Beauty

See More Buffalo Polls & Winners

Things To Do Nearby Nino's Pizza

Recent Reviews In West Seneca

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Eileen's Centerview Bakery Inc

465 Center Rd, West Seneca, NY

Advertisement